Would You Pay More to Guarantee Your Stuff Is Recycled?

Stewardship Ontario has recently started a program called Orange Drop whereby retailers can participate in recycling programs for some of the goods they sell. Photo: Stock

Shoppers in Ontario, Canada might be surprised to find the item “Eco Fee” suddenly listed at the bottom of their retail receipts, a new reality that became effective July 1.

The fees coincide with Stewardship Ontario’s July1 launch of the “Orange Drop” program, North America’s first jurisdiction to launch a single program for the management of 22 types of household materials requiring special handling when they become waste.

This Municipal Hazardous and Special Waste (MHSW) program manages paint, pharmaceuticals, petroleum products, batteries,  fertilizers, pesticides and fluorescent lights, among others.

The first phase of this program launched in July 2008 with nine material categories including paint, pesticides, antifreeze and other automotive products. In 2009, that program diverted approximately 16.6 million pounds of paint and coatings, 16.9 million pounds of oil filters and 880,000 pounds of batteries from landfills and waterways, to list a few.

The July 1 launch expands the Orange Drop program into a new phase, adding 13 additional material categories, estimated to divert approximately 59.5 million pounds from landfills and waterways each year.

Stewardship Ontario, the government-regulated group set up to oversee mandated Ontario recycling programs, insists this program is not a “tax grab” but merely a fee that retailers can opt to pass on to their customers, or absorb themselves.

“Orange Drop is designed to raise awareness about what is considered a hazardous or special waste and to encourage Ontarians to make returning these items part of their regular recycling routine,” said Lyle Clarke, Vice President of Operations for Stewardship Ontario.

The fees are levied to “stewards,” the companies that make or distribute the products able to be recovered through the Orange Drop program. Stewards pay a fee based on the amount of materials put in to the marketplace. These fees range from one cent per liter for “liquid cough medication” pharmaceuticals to $6.66 per “large fire extinguisher.”

How the stewards choose to manage their fees is outside the authority of Stewardship Ontario. They may choose to absorb the cost of their fees, pass it along to their product’s sticker price or make the cost transparent by itemizing it on the cash register receipt.

According to Stewardship Ontario, every cent received from stewards is used to pay for a program to keep hazardous products out of landfills and waterways, leading us to pose the question: Would you pay more to fund the collection and recycling of the hazardous products you purchased and used?

UPDATE:
July 20, 2010 4:50 EDT

The Ontario government has officially scrapped eco fees in response to consumer backlash. However, taxpayers aren’t completely off the hook. According to CTV News, although the fees will be removed from products, the government will pay up to $5 million over the next 90 days to keep the recycling program going.

Related articles
Pay-As-You-Throw Programs Prove to Be Successful
Yes, You Pay More For CFLs, But Are They Worth It?
New Yorkers to Pay an Extra 5 Cents for Bottled Water

Recent Posts

Comments

  1. I would be willing to pay if we had curb pick-up.As things stand now after paying the fee I have to dispose of them myself by driving around to perhaps 20 different drop- offs .From an ecological perspective this makes no sense because of the extra burning of fossil fuels and the pollution from auto exhaust. A fleet of trucks
    collecting them makes more sense.

    As things stand now I will not be dropping anything off—it’s all going in the garbage can. Brilliant plan Dalton.

  2. What a terribly misleading headline. Please explain to me how on earth these eco fees “guarantee” they will be handed any differently than they are now. It is still up to the consumer.

    My closest drop off point is 20 miles away. Do a little more research into this before writing such a ridiculous article. Green Kool-Aid makes for poor journalism.

  3. Hello Lori,

    Excellent article! Congratulations to Ontario, Canada for getting the ball rolling in making a responsible move to help the environment. People say they want to be responsible for helping make sure that less ends up in the trash, well this “Eco Fee” will hopefully help defray some of the cost factors invoved in making sure specific items get recycled instead of being disposed of improperly.I like the fact that the whole recycling process is starting to evolve.

Leave a Comment